Peer Review Process

Peer Review Guideline:

All manuscripts submitted to our journals are thoroughly peer-reviewed by experts.

  1. After submission, the journal’s Managing Editor will perform a technical pre-check of the manuscript. A suitable academic editor will be notified of the submission and invited to perform an editorial pre-check and recommend reviewers. They may accept the manuscript, reject it, or decide to proceed with the review.
  2. Plagiarism check using Turnitin is conducted for each submitted manuscript.
  3. The peer-review process follows a double-blind approach, ensuring that the identities of both reviewers and authors remain anonymous to each other. Reviewers are given a review form provided by the Jamalullail Journal.
  4. Based on the reviewers' feedback, the editor notifies the author whether the manuscript is accepted, requires revisions, or rejected.
  5. If revisions are requested, the author has the opportunity to revise the manuscript according to the reviewers' comments and suggestions. Additionally, the author may submit a response letter addressing each comment and explaining the changes made.
  6. After making the necessary revisions, the author resubmits the revised manuscript. If the reviewer is satisfied with the revisions, the editor notifies the author of the manuscript's acceptance for publication.
  7. The accepted manuscript undergoes the final editorial process before publication, focusing on content consistency and adherence to journal guidelines. Once completed, the article is published online. After finalizing these processes, the paper is published online.